CFB Index
June 22, 2026 · Dead Period · Heritage Window · 2026 Outlook

Buffalo

5-7 2025 final

Buffalo is the Mid-American program known for the bulls.

The Bulls hold the line.

Record
5-7
win% .416
SP+
-1.9
Bowl Odds
Season closed
Year-over-Year
5 wins
Dead PeriodOffseasonPatientPost-loss — reckoning
The Long Wait·Offseason

Buffalo enters the 2026 season at 5-7.

2025 Record5-7
offseason · quiet
Read the full program story ↓

Offseason

69 days

until kickoff · Sun Aug 30 · 17:00 UTC

Act I

The 2026 Outlook

2026 Preview Thesis 2026 Evidence-validated

Buffalo's 2026 season hinges on balanced portal churn and high continuity

The team returns 66% of its roster with a depth class ranked #92, but faces challenges in key positions like CB and LB.

  • Roster reloadBuffalo has a balanced portal churn with 16 transfers in and 16 out, maintaining high continuity with 66% of its roster returning.
Data as of 2026-06-21 · Validated against program evidence

Offseason Pulse · Buffalo

Roster · Recruiting · Portal

Recruiting Class

#92 nationally

2025 cycle · 247 composite rating 155.6

Outside the recruiting top 60. Roster gaps must close via portal.

Returning Production

66%

2025 cycle · CFBD weighted

Above-average continuity. QB transition under way.

Talent Composite

#112 nationally

2025 cycle · 247 composite 513.3

Outside the talent top 60. The wins must be earned in development.

Portal Movement

16 in / 16 out

2026 cycle · in 16 / out 16

Incoming and outgoing movement are tracked separately in Roster Reload.

Buffalo · the story right now 1 storyline developing

What Buffalo's offseason is really about

the open questionwhere does it go from here?

this cycle✓ factnew

Buffalo enters 2025 rated No. 95 in SP+ (-7.5), down 8 spots from 2024.

why it mattersBuffalo enters 2025 at No. 95 in SP+ — Pete Lembo's first season opens with a losing record and talent rank outside the top 100.
narrative tension · our read

Roster Reload - Buffalo

2026 snapshot - 2026-06-21
Returning Production66%High continuity
Portal Additions16Primary repair: LB
Portal Losses16Primary pressure: CB
Draft Loss1NFL Draft departures (1)
Recruiting Reload#92Depth class (#92)
DLin 2 - Stantavious Smith3.40out 3 - Junior Poyser3.60Downgrade
EDGEin 3 - Logan Goodwin3.40out 2 - Demetrius Ballard3.50Even
LBin 3 - Joey Cheshire3.40out 1 - Dion Crawford3.50Need Filled
CBin 1 - Sayre Smothers3.60out 3 - Eddie Pleasant III3.49Starter Risk
WRin 0out 2 - Victor Snow3.60Starter Risk
Sin 0out 2 - Jalen McNair3.50Starter Risk

The Pulse on Buffalo

Archive · Late Spring · 600 mentions · medium confidence
67
Δ +8.1 vs last wk
600 mentions this week · conversation velocity

What moved it — offseason · last 30 days

June Dead-period quiet — official-visit + heritage window
Camp Fall camp ~40 days out
"Go Bulls." — Buffalo fanbase · recurring line

Five Lenses

What people are saying right now

Aspiration Ladder

Brief Part III §33.4 · Buffalo

Bowl eligibility (6 wins)

The baseline goal for a program at this stage.

Beat a rival

The narrative win the season is graded by.

Statement year

Exceed last season by 2+ wins.

Conference championshipLocked

Out of reach without a transformative year.

Buffalo · Next-Season Outcome Band

Floor / Base / Ceiling

floor4-8No postseason.
base7-6Bowl game.
ceiling9-4Bowl game.

Final-season-aware projection: floor / base / ceiling include conference title and CFP games where the model supports them, so a ceiling can exceed a 12-game regular season.

Market outlook

Season expectations

Win total3 booksO/U 5.5
CFP championship#108 in field+100000
MAC title#8 in market+1300

Sportsbook consensus · best odds across multiple books · 2026-06-22

Recruiting Reload - Top 3 commits

2026 class
★★★☆☆
Malachi Ervin
EDGE · Pickerington, OH
#474 national
★★★☆☆
Qur'an McNeill
QB · Milton, MA
#1320 national
★★★☆☆
Na'Rod Jarvis
LB · Chesapeake, VA
#1924 national

Recruiting Footprint · 2026

16
OH · 5NJ · 4PA · 2FL · 1MA · 1MI · 1NY · 1VA · 1

OH leads the 2026 class with 5 commits. National footprint reaching 8 states.

Where they recruit · 2023-2026

67 signees across 26 states, 2023-2026. OH leads the pull.

MEVTNHWAIDMTNDMNWIMINYMAORNVWYSDIAILINOHPANJCTCAUTCONEMOKYWVVAMDDERIAZNMKSARTNNCSCDCOKLAMSALGAAKHITXFL
Source CFB Index · player_recruiting_profiles
Act II

Who We Are

Program Prestige · Buffalo

Mid-Major Contender

Mid-Major Contender — G5 force with occasional national attention.

T1Regional
T2Mid-Major
T3Power
T4National
T5Blue Blood
T6Dynasty
T7All-Time

Model Consensus

Where the Models Rank Buffalo

CFB Index

#97

-1.9

SP+

#95

-7.5

FPI

#116

-13.3

Elo

#104

1298

SRS

#119

-14.2

The national models put Buffalo between 95th and 119th nationally — the CFB Index agrees, slotting them 97th.

National rank of 136 FBS teams · 2025 season. SP+/FPI/SRS published; Elo & CFB Index ranked by rating.

Most Similar Programs · Buffalo

Reads Like

Static-attribute similarity across tier, archetype, conference, and voice. Not a prediction — a calibration.

Coaching Era · Buffalo

Pete Lembo

Pete Lembo took over from Maurice Linguist for the 2025 season.

Era Pete Lembo · 2025–presentPrev: Maurice Linguist (2021–2024)
1 year · era

Fanbase Health Index · Buffalo · medium confidence

Growing (63)

DecliningStableGrowingSurging
On-Field — 5-7 (42% win rate)53
Volume — 127 effective signal-N72

Home-Field Advantage · Buffalo · 2018-present

Strong

48% home win rate vs 46% on the road. margin runs +9.3 better at home.

Home16-17Away15-17

Chronicle Visuals

6 deterministic SVG · provenance-gated
2026 preview

Among the most continuous rosters into 2025 — 66% back, anchored by the offense, only qb room to settle.

Among the most continuous rosters into 2025 — 66% back, anchored by the offense, only qb room to settle.QB room is the stress point for 2025. Source: CFB Index — returning production vs the FBS average (dashed = league avg) · 2025 · high confidenceRETURNING PRODUCTION · 2025Among the most continuous rosters into2025 — 66% back, anchored by theoffense, only qb room to settle.QB roomQB room: 36% returning36%OffenseOffense: 66% returning66%OverallOverall: 66% returning66%▸ QB room is the stress point for 2025.Source: CFB Index — returning production vs the FBS average(dashed = league avg) · 2025 · high confidence
model-confident
2026 preview

The portal upgraded the IOL room but opened a hole at CB.

The portal upgraded the IOL room but opened a hole at CB.Net +0 · upgraded IOL · hole at CB. Source: CFB Index — transfer portal in/out by position (count) · 2026 · 16 in / 16 out · high confidenceTRANSFER PORTAL · 2026The portal upgraded the IOL room butopened a hole at CB.OUTINCBCB: 3 out3CB: 1 in1net -2DLDL: 3 out3DL: 2 in2net -1EDGEEDGE: 2 out2EDGE: 3 in3net +1IOLIOL: 2 in2net +2LBLB: 1 out1LB: 3 in3net +2LSLS: 1 in1net +1OTOT: 1 out1OT: 1 in1net 0PP: 1 out1P: 1 in1net 0QBQB: 1 in1net +1RBRB: 1 out1net -1SS: 2 out2net -2TETE: 1 in1net +1WRWR: 2 out2net -2▸ Net +0 · upgraded IOL · hole at CB.Source: CFB Index — transfer portal in/out by position(count) · 2026 · 16 in / 16 out · high confidence
model-confident
2026 preview

1 player drafted in 2026; the reload runs through the portal and recruiting.

1 player drafted in 2026; the reload runs through the portal and recruiting.1 drafted · 1 capital units. Source: CFB Index — round-weighted draft capital lost by position + portal answers · 2026 · low confidenceNFL DRAFT · 20261 player drafted in 2026; the reloadruns through the portal and recruiting.LBLB: 1 pick1 pick+3 portal▸ 1 drafted · 1 capital units.Source: CFB Index — round-weighted draft capital lost byposition + portal answers · 2026 · low confidence
early signal
2026 preview

Buffalo sits where recruit talent and draft yield largely match.

Buffalo sits where recruit talent and draft yield largely match.Talent 15th, draft yield 20th among 132 programs. Source: CFB Index — recruit talent vs draft-pick yield · 2025 · 132 programs · high confidenceBUFFALO · TALENT YIELDBuffalo sits where recruit talent anddraft yield largely match.Recruit talent (percentile) →Draft yield (percentile) →Georgia — 99 / 99 pctileBaylor — 73 / 35 pctileWashington State — 28 / 64 pctileCentral Michigan — 8 / 43 pctileOld Dominion — 7 / 51 pctileBuffalo — 15 / 20 pctileBuffaloWashington StateOld DominionCentral MichiganGeorgiaBaylor▸ Talent 15th, draft yield 20th among 132 programs.Source: CFB Index — recruit talent vs draft-pick yield ·2025 · 132 programs · high confidence
model-confident
2024 season

A different team every week in 2024 — huge swings, no settled identity.

A different team every week in 2024 — huge swings, no settled identity.a different team every week, with no settled identity. Source: CFB Index — per-game power-rating swings · 2024 · 10 games · high confidenceTHE WEEK-TO-WEEK RIDE · 2024A different team every week in 2024 —huge swings, no settled identity.Game 1: -2.35 power swingGame 2: -2.35 power swingGame 3: +0.72 power swingGame 4: +0.72 power swingGame 5: +1.18 power swingGame 6: +1.18 power swingGame 7: +0.74 power swingGame 8: +0.74 power swingGame 9: -1.08 power swingGame 10: -1.08 power swing-2.4▲ stock-up week▼ stock-down week▸ a different team every week, with no settled identity.Source: CFB Index — per-game power-rating swings · 2024 · 10games · high confidence
model-confident
2024 season

W 34-3 vs Massachusetts leads the season's top 5 results by combined power and résumé delta.

W 34-3 vs Massachusetts leads the season's top 5 results by combined power and résumé delta.W 34-3 vs Massachusetts is the biggest mover. Source: CFB Index — results ranked by combined power + résumé impact · top 5 games · medium confidenceSTATEMENT WINS · TOP 5 RESULTSW 34-3 vs Massachusetts leads theseason's top 5 results by combined powerand résumé delta.W 34-3 vs MassachusettsW 34-3 vs Massachusetts — +2.10 résumé impactW 34-3 vs Massachusetts — +2.10 résumé impact+2.10W 23-20 vs Northern IllinoisW 23-20 vs Northern Illinois — +1.36 résumé impact+1.36L 0-38 vs MissouriL 0-38 vs Missouri — -0.26 résumé impact-0.26L 3-47 vs UConnL 3-47 vs UConn — -1.69 résumé impact-1.69W 30-13 vs LafayetteW 30-13 vs Lafayette — -2.35 résumé impact-2.35▸ W 34-3 vs Massachusetts is the biggest mover.Source: CFB Index — results ranked by combined power +résumé impact · top 5 games · medium confidence
solid read
How the room reactedreal evidence · tap rooms to explore
FOLLOWING NOW · BUFFALO · SEASON OUTLOOK Confidence

Buffalo enters the season in the middle of the pack. That's the whole tension.

Buffalo enters 2025 rated No. 95 in SP+ (-7.5), down 8 spots from 2024. SP+ is a tempo-free efficiency model — it describes what the program HAS done. The season is the test of whether it's still true. The preview consensus leans in — but preseason ratings reward the recent past, not the season ahead.

near-unanimous belief where the takes land · dot = how loud
DOUBTBELIEF
Believers6 bull takes
💬 fans: 7% volume · mostly neutral
CFB INDEX READ · our read
Buffalo enters 2025 at No. 95 in SP+ — Pete Lembo's first season opens with a losing record and talent rank outside the top 100.
Source of record: Buffalo enters 2025 rated No. 95 in SP+ (-7.5), down 8 spots from 2024.

Every line is a door. Evidence opens in place — verbatim outlet headlines for news sources, verbatim fan text attributed to the community not the individual (never a username). Works with JavaScript off.

HOW EACH ROOM IS REACTING — TAP TO EXPAND
The Believers bullishThe Skeptics no dissentThe Boards thin
📣THE BELIEVERS6 bullish/recruiting items — the case it's working.

The optimistic read: recruiting wins, momentum, and the 'this is real' takes.

“Dallas, Buffalo, Green Bay, Las Vegas and Boston Drive Massive Sports Tourism Wave as American Airlines Launches Special NFL Fan Flights Across the United States—Could Football Travel Become America’s Biggest Seasonal Aviation Trend?”
Travel And Tour World · 2026-06-22 · read ↗
“Fantasy Football Target Practice: 2026 Buffalo Bills”
Fantasy Footballers Podcast · 2026-06-18 · read ↗
“Sabres trade targets: What are Buffalo’s options to replace Alex Tuch if he leaves?”
The New York Times · 2026-06-16 · read ↗
🧐THE SKEPTICSNo prominent dissent — the coverage runs one way.

The analytical counter: rankings, results and 'the hype is ahead of the tape' takes.

Nothing in our corpus yet — this door stays open for when there is.

💬THE BOARDS13 board mentions — too thin to call a stance. Board mood this week: mostly neutral · anger notable (32%).

Only 13 of 174 board posts mention it — below our floor to call a community stance. Shown as texture, not a verdict.

"im been accepted to UB and Buffalo state for undergrad whats program is best to pick for UB Accounting BS at Buffalo state Business administration or Economic and finance thank you"
r/UBreddit fan
"You can request one right now and my guess is you’ll hear back during the first month of the semester (that’s when I got mine at least)"
r/UBreddit fan

Board health this week (34 posts): 18% positive · 73% neutral · 9% negative. Team-level weekly mood — not specific to this event. The boards ≠ the fanbase: a self-selected vocal slice.

Act III

Last Season Reviewed

2025 season · tap to expand

Recent Form · last 10 games

Cold

One of five. The film room is busy this week.

Streak L3Last 5 · 1-4Last 10 · 4-6

Season Standing · 2025 · 5-7

FBS sub-.500

Buffalo: Below .500 in FBS play. The rebuild bar.

Sub-FBSBuildingBowlRankedContenderPlayoff

Mid-American Standing · 2025

8th in the Mid-American

Buffalo is 8th of 13 in the Mid-American at 5-7. The path to the title is steep — the focus is on bowl access and rivalry wins.

#ProgramRecord
1Western Michigan10-4
2Ohio9-4
3Toledo8-5
4Sacramento State7-5
5Central Michigan7-6
6Miami (OH)7-7
7Akron5-7
8Buffalo5-7
9Kent State5-7
10Ball State4-8
11Bowling Green4-8
12Eastern Michigan4-8
13Massachusetts0-12

Schedule Strength · Buffalo · 2025

Soft

Average opponent win rate 42% across 12 finalized games. Few elite opponents on the slate — win quality matters for the at-large bracket.

Opp Win %0.426
Top-250
Top-100

Top Players · 2025

2025
1. Khalil Murdock LB 142 tot (def)
2. Nik McMillan WR 975 yds (rec)
3. Dion Crawford LB 79.0 tot (def)
4. Miles Greer S 74.0 tot (def)
5. Mitchell Gonser LB 70.0 tot (def)

NFL Draft Pipeline

2026–2026

Thin

1 picks last 5 cycles. Roster development still maturing.

1 picks · 0 R1
#257 Red Murdock Linebacker · 2026 · Denver

Moment of the Year · Buffalo · 2025

Won 45-6 vs St. Francis (PA)

Week 2 of 2025. A statement margin. Recruiting boards re-rendered overnight.

Decisive Margin

Bowl / Postseason Ledger

Recent postseason (2022-2024): 2-0

Most recent: 2024 — win 7-26 (away). Last 5 postseason: 2-0.

20242022

From the Archive — Buffalo

Postseason 2022: Won 23-21 vs Georgia Southern

In 2022, the program won 23-21 vs Georgia Southern in the postseason — a tight home result that left the 2-point margin on the books.

Go Bulls.