CFB IndexWhere every team stands · what every fanbase thinks
Matchup SimulatorCompare Teams

FCS CONFERENCE · 2025 SEASON

Pioneer

#22 overall#11 in FCSRR50 +8.5Upper strength +10.911 teamsTop 25 teams 0

THE LONG WAIT · 2025

No Scholarships, No Excuses

The Pioneer Football League is the only non-scholarship FCS conference. Programs like Dayton, San Diego, Drake, and Marist compete without offering athletic scholarships — the same model as the Ivy League, but with FCS playoff eligibility. Dayton has won eight Pioneer titles since 2002 and regularly makes the FCS bracket. The conference proves that the scholarship-and-playoff model is not the only way to run competitive football at the FCS level, and that walk-on-heavy rosters can win postseason games.

Dayton has been the conference's anchor for two decades. San Diego and Drake both have the roster depth to challenge. Does the Pioneer's playoff bid go to a new program in 2026, or does Dayton's system make them the default favorite every year regardless of the bracket format?

FCS11 teamsRace: FCS Playoff

Pioneer · 2026 Season Preview

Three Things to Watch

The DynastyDayton: Eight Titles Without a Scholarship

Dayton has won eight Pioneer Football League titles since 2002 and made multiple FCS bracket appearances — all without offering athletic scholarships. Rick Chamberlin's program develops walk-ons into FCS playoff performers at a rate that scholarship programs at the same level cannot match. They enter 2026 as the default conference favorite, as they have been in every year of the last two decades, and they are very likely to validate that expectation again.

The ChallengerSan Diego's West Coast Case

The University of San Diego plays on a mesa overlooking Mission Bay. They are a small Catholic university that competes in the Pioneer Football League and has won multiple conference titles. Their recruiting pipeline — Southern California skill players who choose academics over scholarship offers at larger programs — is one of the Pioneer's best-kept secrets. They have beaten Dayton in the Pioneer championship game, and they have the roster to do it again in 2026.

The Model

What the Pioneer Proves Every Year

The Pioneer Football League proves every season that non-scholarship football can be genuinely competitive at the FCS level. Programs like Dayton, San Diego, Drake, and Marist develop players who chose academics, who weren't recruited by scholarship programs, who are at these schools for reasons beyond football — and who still compete for national championships. The Pioneer is the FCS answer to the Ivy League model, with postseason eligibility added.

Conference Standings · Pioneer · 2025

Standings

# Team Conf Overall Pwr Last 5
1Drake7–18–4+9.6
2Presbyterian6–210–2+12.4
3San Diego6–28–4+11.0
4Dayton5–37–4+11.2
5St. Thomas (MN)5–37–5+10.1
6Butler4–46–6+8.0
7Morehead State4–46–6+7.4
8Marist3–55–7+8.4
9Stetson2–63–9+4.5
10Valparaiso1–72–10+5.1
11Davidson1–72–10+4.3

Conference record determines standing. Power = neutral-field pts vs. all-level average. Last 5 = most recent game results.

Projected Standings · Pioneer · 2025

Win Projection

Odds of winning at least N conference games from current power ratings — full slate played out, not locked to results. AVG = expected wins; W–L = most-likely record.

# Team W–L PWR AVG ≥8≥7≥6≥5≥4≥3≥2≥1
Favorites
1Presbyterian5–3+4.04.92123463859699✓
2Dayton5–3+2.84.6182754799499✓
Challengers
3San Diego5–3+2.64.6182754799499✓
4St. Thomas (MN)4–4+1.74.4162248749198✓
5Drake4–4+1.34.3151943719098✓
6Marist4–4+0.04.031436648697✓
The Field
7Morehead State4–4-0.93.931334618496✓
8Butler4–4-0.33.72102957819599
9Valparaiso3–5-3.23.2151842709099
Rebuilding
10Stetson3–5-3.93.2151841709099
11Davidson3–5-4.13.1141537658898

Conference Power · FCS

Where We Stand

# Conference Avg Power vs Focal Top Team
1MVFC
+10.2
0–7North Dakota State
2Big Sky
+9.6
0–4Montana State
3MEAC
+9.4
—South Carolina State
4UAC
+9.3
1–1Tarleton State
5SWAC
+9.1
—Alabama State
6Southland
+9.1
—Stephen F. Austin
7CAA
+8.9
0–1Villanova
8Patriot
+8.7
0–2Lehigh
9Big South-OVC
+8.6
1–3Tennessee Tech
10PioneerYou are here
+8.5
—Presbyterian
11Southern
+8.4
2–1Mercer
12NEC
+8.2
3–0Central Connecticut
13Ivy
+7.7
1–2Yale

Round-robin power = strength of schedule-adjusted conference average, points vs. all-level average team. Record = Pioneer's record vs. that conference across all games this season.

Pioneer is outperforming its raw power profile. The league body of work is stronger than the market would expect.

Conference Snapshot

RR50+8.5
Upper Strength+10.9
Median Power+8.6
Resume Pulse50.8
Avg ATS48.9%
Wins vs Market+0.32
Top-to-Middle Gap4.0
Combined Record64-67

`RR50`, `Upper Strength`, and `Median Power` are shown on the same public power scale as the rest of the site: points on a neutral field versus the average all-level NCAA team. Very small affiliations are gently regressed toward their subdivision baseline so a one-team outlier does not hijack the entire conference board.

Pioneer Team Board

The league stack, sorted by predictive strength. Power is shown as neutral-field points versus the all-level average team, while resume is shown on a 0-100 season score.

Rank Team Record Power Resume ATS Wins vs Market Recent Form
#98 Presbyterian 10-2 +12.4 92 5-5 +1.07 3-1 over the last 4 (W10 L11 W12 W13)
#127 Dayton 7-4 +11.2 72 5-5 +0.22 2-2 over the last 4 (W9 L10 L12 W13)
#136 San Diego 8-4 +11.0 76 6-6 +1.12 4-0 over the last 4 (W10 W11 W12 W13)
#162 St. Thomas (MN) 7-5 +10.1 78 7-4 -0.33 2-2 over the last 4 (W10 W11 L12 L13)
#178 Drake 8-4 +9.6 77 6-4 +0.82 2-2 over the last 4 (L11 W12 W13 L14)
#204 Marist 5-7 +8.4 52 8-4 +0.52 2-2 over the last 4 (L10 W11 W12 L13)
#210 Butler 6-6 +8.0 39 5-5 -0.24 1-3 over the last 4 (L10 L11 L12 W13)
#221 Morehead State 6-6 +7.4 36 5-5 +0.97 3-1 over the last 4 (W9 W10 W11 L13)
#252 Valparaiso 2-10 +5.1 15 4-6 -0.43 1-3 over the last 4 (L10 L11 W12 L13)
#257 Stetson 3-9 +4.5 10 3-7 +0.54 0-4 over the last 4 (L9 L11 L12 L13)
#260 Davidson 2-10 +4.3 13 3-8 -0.79 1-3 over the last 4 (L10 W11 L12 L13)